The Starlight Tavern

142 Reviews (4.5 Rating)
Advertisement

The business details and user reviews shown for The Starlight Tavern are based on information sourced from Google Maps. This place has a total of 142 reviews on Google, but for performance and readability we display up to the 15 most recent reviews on our website.
If you are the owner or representative of this business and would like it to be removed from our directory, please use the "Remove Request" button at the top of this page. All information is provided for informational purposes only and may not always reflect the most recent changes made on Google Maps.

This listing for The Starlight Tavern was first added to our directory on December 18, 2025 based on the information available at that time. It is currently listed as a Bar & grill in Brooklyn, US.

15 Reviews for The Starlight Tavern

Garrett Wheeler

3 years ago

Starlight is back and better than ever! I used to live next door and would frequent this place pre-covid. Now it’s back with delicious food (seriously, the mac and cheese is amazing) and great cocktails. …

Ashlee Pitock

3 years ago

The food and drink is really solid! We got the fried pickles and onion rings and they were 5/5 delicious. The bartender Drew was awesome! Will be back.

Eddy Katt

a year ago

Very chill, old school bar vibes. Budweiser Clydesdale lamp and everything. Customer service is excellent, Anthony will take care of you.

Sean Dykhouse

4 years ago

I'm so glad this bar was here for us before the Rona, and I'm looking forward to when they're back at it. They serve my favorite cocktails, and the meats just can't be beat! The staff have always been friendly and kind and I have yet to find anything on the menu that I don't love. High marks!

Angela Wong

10 months ago

we had the best service! the bartenders were super attentive and soooo friendly. so happy to have come here

Malina Webb

4 weeks ago

Love a quick round of skeeball and great bartenders!!! Cute backyard

Hannah Litman

5 months ago

Perfect dive perfect vibes, please don’t go here and ruin it 🫶🏻 skeeball!! Outdoor space! …

Matthew Torres

a year ago

Love this place. Has an amazing vibe with the cool 70s theme. Good bartenders consistently. Food is pretty good, I’ve gotten a few items that have all satisfied. Kitchen is open late. They also have Skee Ball!

Yamil Aloyo Corcino

3 years ago

Great, afoordable, chilled low-key ambience neighborhood bar with a back patio. Loved it!

Max

a year ago

I used to come on a regular basis, it was such a nice place. The person behind the bar was great and the music as well. …

Madeline

2 months ago

Travis is the best. The food is fast and fresh, just what you need. Great beers on tap. Killer bloody Marys. Great outdoor area. Ski ball. Cozy lighting. What more could you ask for?

Michelle Mitchell

Edited a year ago

Review: Starlight Tavern, Williamsburg, Brooklyn

If you’re looking for a venue that perfectly blends great vibes, fantastic …

Brendan Donohue

a year ago

What a blast at starlight tavern. Been for a birthday party , and for a relaxing December evening with friends. Although I did walk in on this freak who would not lock the bathroom door, and I did find a man passed out on the skee ball …

Damien DeJesus

7 months ago

The Starlight Tavern is a local gem. It’s the place you meet up with friends, have some cocktails and enjoy a truly delicious meal. Many restaurants and bars have come and gone over the years - but it’s the unique combination of great food, …

Andrew Brownfield

6 years ago

Bartender was super welcoming. Ambiance was perfect. No pretension, just a good time. I loved the TV aquarium and parogis... and no, I didn't eat the aquarium!